Shades Of Words

Death at President’s Lodging

3 Comments

Death at President's Lodging

Winter is the perfect time to read the British murder mystery novels, though I have always wondered why this genre is so popular in England. What is this fascination with cold blooded murders in closed country houses? In The Suspicions of Mr. Whicher, Kate Summerscale explains how the murder at the Road Hill house caught the nations fancy and inspired an entire generation of literature and must have laid the foundation for the Golden Age of the detective fiction and some of the first detectives in England.

There is something very genteel about the British mystery novel. There is no gore or loud action or twists and turns. There is suspense and the plot peels off in oniony layers, but it’s never scary. As a reader, you can sip a cup of tea and breeze through a novel which engages your mind pleasantly for a few hours.

Death at President’s Lodging plot is very similar to any “closed house limited number of suspects” murder stories. The crime happens, as the name suggests, at the President’s Lodgings in St. Anthony’s college. Since this is a college campus and is open to public during the day, the murderer could be anyone in the village. However, the access to the lodging is limited and controlled by a set of keys which are in the hands of a few people. The access to the college in which the lodge is located is limited at night and controlled by a set of keys, which is again the in the hands of a few people. All the possible suspects have air-tight, strangely corroborative alibis.

Michael Innes, employs his favorite detective to unravel the case, Inspector Appleby. The detective on arrival at St. Anthony’s college realizes that the murdered man was clearly not popular man (uh, duh!) and that the suspects are a bunch of formidable intellectual snobs, who are extremely capable of planning a brilliant murder.
Why I recommend this book is, because after a fairly long time, I felt so absorbed in a puzzle. There is something mathematical about the issue of the keys, and the number of entrances to the college and the sequence of events of the night of the murder. The solution to the mystery is really one of the most imaginative though slightly improbable.

Verdict: Highly recommended


8 Comments

Death Comes to Pemberley

Finally after 3 years of marriage, my husband realized that I would love to be gifted a book and gave me one for Christmas. I was visibly excited when I saw it was a PD James and curious to see how it handled the most popular romantic classic of the 19th century and probably the most spun off story in recent times – Pride & Prejudice.

They say imitation is the sincerest form of flattery , but I am convinced that had Miss Austen been alive, she would have felt quite abused by the many versions this story has taken and how her favorite characters have progressed. Ofcourse, quality is not an issue with James, who is a credible writer in her own right, and she begins the novel quite rightly and humbly with an apology to Austen for bringing a sense of morbidity to a world created by her.

James sets the story in Pemberley, several years after the marriage of Darcy and Elizabeth, a few days before the traditional autumn ball. The Wickhams are still estranged from the family and on the eve of the ball, Lydia Wickham makes a dramatic entrance into the Pemberly driveway yelling “ My husband has been murdered !”

Now, one would expect that this would set up the tone for a juicy murder investigation where at least Darcy or Elizabeth would take up a sleuthing role and try to find clues and fit pieces together. But that is not the case.

Using P&P as the prologue to this novel really ties James hands down in terms of plot. A lot of the narrative is spent paraphrasing events from the original novel and explaining the context of the relationship of main characters. Even though she clearly has had fun imagining what happened to the lives of ancillary characters like Mary Bennet, Mr. Collins, Charlotte Collins, Kitty Bennet, Mr, Bingly after P&P ended, most of that has very little to do with the plot. The character growth of some the main players is constrained by what we already know about them and does not fit very well into a murder mystery kind of novel.

The third person narrative is slow, often introspective and has very little to do with the murder at most times.  There is a lot of focus on Darcy’s position in society, his relationship with Wickham, the relationships of the family in general.  PD James has introduced some new characters especially with respect to the Pemberely household but none of them interesting enough to leave an impression.

At the end of it as a reader, you don’t care who died, how he was killed, why he was killed and how was the murderer found out. Not much point to reading the book then, is there?

Unless, I am getting it all wrong and this is not a murder mystery and a period novel in which someone just dies.